2 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Tribunal held that the parties had agreed that the present appeal was covered in favour of the appellant-assessee by the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court dated 26.02.2026 in ITA-517-2008, titled M/s Vardhman Textiles Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and another. In light of this consensus, the questions of law raised through the appeal were answered in favour of the appellant-assessee. The appeal was allowed in terms of the law laid down in M/s Vardhman Textiles Ltd.’s case. Any pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of. No specific issues were left undecided.
The High Court held that the Trial Court had correctly adjudicated the issues and its judgment did not warrant interference. Regarding the first two issues concerning John Bennet's entitlement to the amount claimed in O.S.No.194 of 2009, the Court found that there was abundant oral and documentary evidence adduced by John Bennet. Conversely, Anbu Illam failed to substantiate its claim in O.S.No.130 of 2012. The Court noted that while the appellant (Anbu Illam) concentrated on challenging the admissibility of Ex.A.1 (the agreement), the pleadings and stand during the trial clearly indicated that an agreement for construction did exist. Even if Ex.A.1 were excluded, this fundamental fact could not be disputed. The Court found no evidence apart from bare assertions to establish that any amount had been overpaid to John Bennet or that all dues were settled. Therefore, the appellant had failed to substantiate its case in both suits. The issue of whether a written agreement was entered into on 15.08.2008 was implicitly decided against Anbu Illam, as the Court found the appellant's arguments regarding the agreement's inadmissibility did not advance its case and that an agreement for construction was fundamentally established. The Court dismissed both appeal suits.